Thursday, October 17, 2013

Has Young Adult Fiction Become Too Dark?


Jess Parrott 812

Reading Response: 
Has Young Adult Fiction Become Too Dark? by Mary Elizabeth Williams

“That’s why it matters, why, in the name of protecting teens, we can’t shut them off from the outlet of experiencing difficult events and feelings in the relative safety and profound comfort and literature.”
-       From Has Young Adult Fiction Become Too Dark? by Mary Elizabeth Williams
This quote from Williams’ masterful article really sums up her side of the
argument from the ‘to ban or not to ban’ books debate. Yes, many YA fic books can be dark, and sometimes slightly disturbing. But if teens are never exposed to these sometimes troubling topics, then how will they gain knowledge? It is hard to justify an opinion that is “protecting teens” from these topics if they are being hidden from the truth of the world.
            Many of these topics are not unusual. Some teens do drink alcohol prematurely, and the same with illegal drugs. If a teen who was shrouded from this genre were to encounter these topics, they would probably have little to no prior knowledge. These themes are very real. Hiding them from teens in hope of “saving them from appalling themes in books” might eventually just end with a negative outcome. Profanity, violence, coarseness, misery- these are all already immersed in adolescence. They don’t just come from books. If teens read about these topics in books, this way, they are preparing themselves (in a way) for the future.
            Not all teens are depressed or have gone through some of these dark events or emotions. But some are slightly affected; yet don’t realize it. Reading about these themes in books can help teens realize and understand their changing selves more. Sometimes, a book is someone’s only getaway. And if these books are taken away, who would be there to understand them? Many authorities who are behind these bans claim they know teens. But none of them will ever know what goes on in our heads; and what helps us in a book. Shutting teens off from important topics can be dangerous and damaging. And yes, sometimes, important topics aren’t pretty. But neither is everyone’s future.
            Mary Elizabeth Williams responds beautifully to the banned books debate. She helps show and explain that classics, which are classics for a reason, shouldn’t be taken away from a school library because authorities don’t agree with the themes. She acknowledges that these books are indeed controversial; yet shows why they are needed in teens’ lives. And as Williams states as her closing sentence, “Darkness isn’t the enemy. But ignorance is.”

Sunday, October 6, 2013

Paper Towns by John Green


Jess Parrott, 812
29 September 2013

Reading Response Blog Post:
Paper Towns by John Green

            I have a weak ankle; meaning it gets hurt often. And when I sprained it at sleep away camp last summer, I had to go on crutches. But for that long week and a half, my best friend, Noga, always stood with me. She sacrificed many of her free times to help me to the infirmary and help me get around camp. Everywhere you go; it’s kind of rooty. My camp is spanned over acres of hills and uneven ground; and it’s by a big, open lake. Naturally, constant slopes and roots are a bit of a struggle. Noga helped me in small ways; like getting me food at meals so I didn’t have to wait in the buffet lines, and in big ways, like making me glittery cards and complicated friendship bracelets in arts and crafts. Noga was always at my side to help me with anything and everything, doing what any best friend would do and more. And in Paper Towns, by John Green, friendship is one of the deepest roots that ties all of the characters together.
            The way John Green treated Q’s friendship with Ben and Radar during their search for their missing friend, Margo, helped me learn a lot more about Ben and Radar’s personalities. After knowing each other for so long, I think having a real motive and drive to accomplish something that mattered to all of them in different ways awakened different people in all of them. During the race to find Margo, Q and Ben and Radar all opened up and changed visibly. This is important because in that time in their lives, everything around them was changing. When they graduated, Q had all these complicated inner thoughts about leaving that helped him understand Margo and her drive. In order to keep up with the world around them, it was important that they changed, too. It affected not only their friendship but the people around them.
            During the quest to find Margo, a more adventurous side of Q opens up. Pranking so many people in unthinkably odd and clever ways with Margo changed something inside of him. The sense of danger made him more outgoing. This “new” Q is greeted wearily by Ben and Radar. Ben and Radar were so used to a mellow, average-high-school-student Q that this new and devoted Q took them by surprise. During the time Margo’s missing, Ben seems to find his “inner top dog”. When one of my friends undergoes a big personality change, I try my best to adapt. But when this happened to Ben at Q at the same time, neither or them were ready. Ben becomes more superficial and him and Q become ore hostile. Yet during this, Radar stays sane. When things between Ben and Q go awry, Radar seems to manage Q’s Margo obsession and his newfound love life. Radar evens things out by talking to Q about his friendship philosophies. I think that having Radar talk to Q seriously about friendship brought Q back to reality after being sucked into the search; and helped him salvage his friendship with Ben. I think that this is how they balance each other out. When two of them fight, the other solves the problem. This connects to a lot of Q’s inner thoughts and realizations about friendship. He becomes aware of the checks-and-balances system that is their friendship. It’s just how their bond works. I’ve been in Radar’s position before. Many of my friends come to me for friendship advice and most of
 the time, thankfully, it works. I think in order for their relationship to balance out and remain intact, Q needs to lean into his friends and depend on them a little more.
            Going on such a big and unexpected journey changed all of their lives. Ben and Radar and Q’s friendships were tested; but somehow they just grew stronger. I think this test proved that they not only could tolerate each other for a 24 hour road trip, but could maintain a strong and faithful connection. When one of my friends has a dire and important goal, it is important to help them. Real friends, however cheesy, know when one another need help. And sticking with them is key. When friends make sacrifices for friends then it proves something to all of them. Somehow, that chase changed all of their lives. But it also changed Ben, Radar and Q as people. They all learned, in depth, the true values of friendship and what it means to stay loyal to one another.
           
            

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Reading Response: "Will Grayson, Will Grayson" by John Green & David Leviathan

Over the summer, my (by far) favorite was "Will Grayson, Will Grayson".
(This response may contain spoilers)
John Green is, also by far, my favorite author. But this collaboration with David Leviathan is something to be beat.
The two main characters, Will Grayson (#1) and Will Grayson (#2), alternate chapters from their points of view. At a point in the book, their lives with collide.
One of my favorite qualities of the book is Will Grayson #1's inner thoughts. He leads a pretty mediocre life with a limited social life. He starts off the book with a best friend, Tiny. Tiny is the opposite of Will; with a humongous personality. Essentially, everyone in their school knows who Tiny is. He is has a passion for theatre and singing. And Will is his shadow. I could see a book being written on the same time stream as this book but from Tiny's point of view and it would be interesting. But Will doesn't realize that he is shadowing his friend towards the end of the book. His inner thoughts reveal, subconsciously, that he knows this but at the same time doesn't. Just listening to Will, in a way, narrate Tiny's life with snippets of his own, shows a lot about Will.
I also love Will's relationship with Tiny, in its own category. Especially towards the end when Will realizes that he doesn't have to constantly bask in Tiny's glory. As both Wills' lives intertwine, Will #1 begins to "realize" himself.
But the saddest part of the book is definitely the beginning of Will #2's story. He lives a much worse life than Will #1. Will #2 only has one sort of friend, which he hates. Will is diagnosed with clinical depression, and his mother is not a steady figure in his life. As some would predict, he turns to the internet. There he has met a friend who he loves, Isaac. The best parts of Will #2's chapters are his conversations with his online friend via IM. Outside of their chats, Will is a cynical, depressed and constantly mean kid who hates everything about his life. Except Isaac. And just seeing how Will #2 changes his whole personality online when he's talking to Isaac is one of the most amazing things about the book.
Will Grayson, Will Grayson was depressing, beautifully written, and beautiful to read.