Jess
Parrott 812
Close
Reading The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug
“If this is to end in fire, then we
shall all burn together.” – Thorin (Richard Armitage). The film “The Hobbit:
The Desolation of Smaug” displays the message that above all else, family
matters. In this project, I looked closely at several scenes and characters to
find the emotional depth behind them, shown not only in the screenplay but also
by the characters’ actions.
One of the characters that show
incredible emotional depth is Thorin son of Thrain, the leader of the Dwarf
company and soon-to-be King under the Lonely Mountain, Erebor (played by
Richard Armitage). Thorin initiated the quest to reclaim the mountain and all
its riches from the notorious dragon, Smaug, as a quest of honor. Yet as he
continues on his journey and nears the mountain, his honor starts to
disintegrate. The hunger for gold and treasure increases inside of him and he
starts to forget what really matters most, which is family. I believe that,
deep down inside, Thorin knows what truly matters. But he is letting his wants
get ahead of his needs, his kin. And his kin notice. When Kili, his nephew,
gets shot by a poisoned arrow and starts to die, Thorin almost mindlessly
leaves him behind in Lake-Town. He almost tells Kili himself that his top
priority is reclaiming the mountain, and not his kin, which is every dwarf’s
top priority. Their race is built upon a very strong bond between kin. And when
things start to go really awry, as proved in their history, is when this
priority is damaged. I believe that Thorin is afraid for this to happen,
subconsciously, because this is what happened to his father and his father
before him, and that led to the majority of their kingdom, along with a
neighboring city, to be completely destroyed. Thorin has let his fear and greed
blind him, and soon, will have to pay a price.
Another character that shows a large
amount of emotional depth is Bard the Bowman (played by Luke Evans). Bard,
alike to the dwarves, has a very keen bond and protection with and over his
family. Also alike to the dwarves, he has lost a lot in his past. When they
meet, this emotional scar is very evident in the way they argue for what is
right. Bard expresses hostility toward the dwarves because of what damage they caused
in the past; and how his protection has grown now and he will not let them get
away with damaging any further. But what really sticks out about Bard is how
genuinely human he is. He has such a dear love over his people even though many
of them label him as a troublemaker and a disturber. He protects and fights for
them anyway because he knows the possible misfortune ahead; and will do close
to anything to prevent it. I believe that by standing up to the dwarves, yet
still helping some of them, he can’t help it because of how caring he is. He is
such an honest character and really displays so much humanity in him, which
very strongly contrasts to the rest of the characters, as the majority of them
are not human. Bard brings the almost essential quality of humanity to this
film series in the form of pure devotion.
Another character that has very
complex emotional depth is Thranduil, the Elven King of Mirkwood (played by
[the acting genius that is] Lee Pace). Even though he is only in the film for a
good 20 minutes, he easily has more emotional depth and is more interesting
than the large majority of the characters. When he was much younger, he went
into a very large battle with his father and a very large army, and came back
with possibly 1/3 of his original army and no father. He has experiences a
traumatic amount of loss and damage in his life and it shows in his every word
and action. Elves are immortal, and this seems to be a blessing yet a curse. They
are frozen in one image, not visually aging after a certain time, yet their
souls are so incredibly old. This is visual in Thranduil’s persona; especially
when he interacts with Thorin. Thorin comes into his kingdom asking for help as
he reclaims the mountain. Thranduil offers him a deal; he will help as long as
Thorin returns some long lost jewels. But Thorin refuses, out of pure pride and
greed, and Thranduil throws them in his dungeons. I believe that Thranduil acts
so harshly because he is trying to protect what little kin he has left and his kingdom
as a whole. He responds to actions in very deeply emotional ways; not only because
of his history, but how he reacts to violence. He displays protection over his
kin and his kingdom as a precaution, but to try to crystalize what beauty he
has left in his life but also to protect himself from hurting anymore. The culture
of the Elves, and not only in this film, is so melancholy. And this can only be
defined by their harsh immortality. And Thranduil displays this melancholy
curse in everything he does.
The film “The Hobbit: Desolation of
Smaug” has countless characters with many emotionally deep stories. The film
displays messages of pride, greed, guilt, melancholy, and how important family
is. Not only do the characters have very complex emotions, but the story of “The
Hobbit” itself.

